Exercise #4: Documentary Reflection

October 11, 2023 By: Bruno Knopfel

Environmental movements have roots that stretch back through the years, with tactics like “chaining” oneself to a tree even making their way into popular comedy television shows like “It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia” and “Curb Your Enthusiasm.” Regrettably, in these instances, the intent is often to satirize activists for comedic effect. It’s important to acknowledge, however, that there are many people who participate in acts of civil disobedience with seriousness, even at great personal risk to their physical and mental well-being. They hold the belief that typical methods have proven ineffective and can be seen as a ineffective investment of time. Therefore, they advocate for more radical approaches to gather the attention of both media outlets and government authorities. This reflects a perspective that prioritizes urgent action in the face of pressing environmental concerns.

While the radical approach is not adopted by the majority, it’s crucial to recognize that we are potentially on the brink of facing severe consequences from climate change soon. In this context, the acts of warning and the passionate pleas directed towards major corporations and governments may not seem comical at all. They stand for a growing urgency to focus on the pressing environmental issues that affect us all. As the gravity of the situation becomes increasingly evident, these actions are viewed as crucial efforts to safeguard our planet and future generations.

I have chosen the article regarding Howard Gerald Breen, 69, and Melanie Joy Murray, 48, the couple from Nanaimo who blocked streets and highways for short periods of time to call the attention on the cutting of forests in B.C. Howard and Melanie were arrested by the RCMP, and later claimed their freedom of expression were violated during the arrests. During the trial the judge claimed that their actions conflicted with the values protected under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Breen mentioned he was not surprised by the decision, but called attention to the lack of worry about the current climate emergency we are facing.

This case has similarities with the documentary “If a Tree Falls: A Story of the Earth Liberation Front” by Daniel McGowan. However not nearly as serious, since Daniel ended up being jailed for seven years in federal prison due to involvement with eco-terrorism.

In conclusion, environmental movements and acts of civil disobedience have been part of civilization for decades. More recent, they have grown significantly, increasing attention to the issue of climate change and calling for accountability from major corporations and governments. Taking to the streets to voice concerns and advocate for change is a fundamental right, a cornerstone of freedom of speech that every individual should possess. However, it is essential to draw a distinction: while peaceful protests are the ideal means of expression, destroying property and looting, like cases such as Daniel McGowan’s, are taking the wrong turn.

 

References:

Major, D. (n.d.). Nanaimo “Save Old Growth” protestors lose bid to have court case thrown out. NanaimoNewsNOW | Nanaimo News, Sports, Weather, Real Estate, Classifieds and More. Retrieved October 12, 2023, from https://nanaimonewsnow.com/2023/05/02/nanaimo-save-old-growth-protestors-lose-bid-to-have-court-case-thrown-out/

 

If a Tree Falls: A Story of the Earth Liberation Front (Full Movie). (n.d.). Www.youtube.com. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qwQoi0DoOKM