Exercise #4: Documentary Reflection
Instructions
For your fourth Exercise assignment, you will make connections between the environmental movement in the recent past and today by considering what you are challenged to learn from documentarians of that movement.
- Find a current or recent report in the mainstream or alternative media of an environmental topic or issue in your local or wider region. As you read/ hear about the issue, consider where you stand on it. Identify your position and your thoughts.
- Use the documentaries in this course unit to reflect on the role that civil disobedience has played in the history of environmentalism, researching one other recent example to defend your answer to the question of whether it works to bring positive change.
Use your research in the mainstream and alternative media from Activity 1 of this unit for this exercise Post the media links and your analysis. Aim for a minimum of 300 words.
Please note, you should write and edit your submission in a separate file then copy and paste it into the submission box. Once submitted to the HIST 3991 trubox site, you will not be able to edit your post.
Are you a student of HIST 3991? Click here to add a submission to this assignment.
Submissions
Excersise 4 – Civil Disobedience
May 4, 2024 By: Britnie Hearsey
Civil disobedience has played a significant role in raising awareness and catalyzing change in the history of environmentalism in British Columbia. Examples in my region include protests against logging in old-growth forests and demonstrations against pipelines and fossil fuel projects. Civil disobedience has often drawn attention to environmental issues, mobilized public support, and pressured governments and corporations to reconsider their policies and practices. However, its effectiveness in bringing positive change depends on various factors, including public perception, political will, and the willingness of authorities to engage with protesters’ concerns. While civil disobedience can be a powerful tool for environmental activism,…
Documentary Disucssion
April 8, 2024 By: Danielle Fernstrom
Civil disobedience in the name of environmental protection comes with many intentional and unintentional effects as it can shape the ways a society perceives environmental topics. Civil disobedience has an honourable history; the question of importance is whether a particular group on a particular matter is deemed justified in such actions1. The justification of the actions is just as crucial as the justifications of the outcome. Many ethical theories such as Kantian ethics and Utilitarianism regard an action unethical if the method to achieve the outcome is unethical to start with. With civil disobedience for the sake of the environment…
Documentary reflection
March 25, 2024 By: Sam McQuillan-Gordon
Documentary reflection When I first saw the description for this assignment and read the words “civil disobedience”, “conservation” and “local area” my mind immediately went to the ongoing Fairy Creek Anti-Logging protests that received enormous media coverage during the early 2020s. British Columbia has a long relationship with “save the trees” movements, dating back to the 1960s. However, lumber is still one of B.C’s principal exports so the efficacy of these protests is still open for debate. The ongoing protests against old-growth logging in the Fairy Creek watershed on Vancouver Island represent a significant moment in Canadian environmental activism. With…
Documentary Reflection
March 22, 2024 By: Navraj Randhawa
Considering the book “Canadians and the Natural Environment to the Twenty-First Century,” let’s discuss the role of civil disobedience in environmentalism. Firstly, civil disobedience has historically played a significant role in the environmental movement. Documentaries such as “An Inconvenient Truth” by Al Gore and “Before the Flood” by Leonardo DiCaprio showcase the urgency and necessity of direct action to address environmental issues like climate change. Civil disobedience has often been used as a tool to raise awareness, disrupt harmful practices, and pressure governments and corporations to take action. One recent example of civil disobedience making an impact is the global…
Documentary Reflection
February 28, 2024 By: Jin Yi Wu
Definition Mainstream media refers to traditional forms of media like radio, television, newspapers, and magazines that are easily accessible. On the other hand, alternative media consists of independently owned news websites, publications, and digital media that provide different perspectives and may be harder to access compared to mainstream sources. Alternative Media The varying viewpoints presented by the Trans Mountain website, Eco-Justice website, and Energy Humanities website provide contrasting stances on the Trans Mountain Pipeline, particularly highlighting its impact on Indigenous Peoples and the environment. The Trans Mountain website emphasizes extensive engagement with Indigenous communities and groups, manifesting a commitment to…