Exercise #3: Connecting Past and Present
Instructions
For Exercise #3, you will make connections between what you have learned in the course about the past and what is happening today through contemporary media.
- Find two recent media items thematically connected in some way to two of the three topics covered in Unit 3: conservation, parks, and urbanization. For each of these, post a paragraph of three to five sentences, connecting the media story to what you learned, or were challenged to consider, from the resources in Unit 3. Provide the web link to the article in each post.
- These postings may be informal but should be grammatically correct. You should be respectful of other students’ opinions, but that does not mean you must agree with their ideas.
- Post your response by clicking ‘Add Submission’ below.
- Then post two separate comments responding to any other student’s posts.
- Please note, you should write and edit your submission in a separate file then copy and paste it into the submission box. Once submitted to the HIST 3991 trubox site, you will not be able to edit your post.
Are you a student of HIST 3991? Click here to add a submission to this assignment.
Submissions
Connecting Past and Present
August 12, 2026 By: Rhys Parry
Media Item 1: Parks Movement I found it interesting that Canada and B.C. are increasingly working with First Nations to create and manage protected areas. This seems very different from what Binnema and Niemi describe at Banff, where Indigenous peoples were excluded from the park partly because of conservation, tourism, sport hunting, and assimilation. It also connects to Cronon’s argument that what we think of as untouched “wilderness” is actually shaped by human ideas and history. To me, Indigenous-led protected areas challenge the older idea that protecting nature requires separating people from the land. Media Link: https://www.canada.ca/en/parks-canada/news/2026/05/mia-yaltwa-halidzogm-hoon-a-collaborative-approach-to-marine-protection-announced-for-the-central-coast-of-british-columbia.html Media Item…
Exercise #3: Connecting Past and Present
August 5, 2026 By: Lingling Hu
Media Item: “Xinhua Headlines: Pocket parks drive urban renewal, eco-improvement efforts in China” http://www.china.org.cn/china/Off_the_Wire/2026-07/24/content_118615867.shtml This article describes how China is building thousands of “pocket parks”—small green spaces typically covering 400 to 10,000 square meters—across cities to enhance urban living conditions, with over 18,000 built between 2021 and 2025 as part of a national urban renewal plan (“Xinhua Headlines: Pocket”, 2026). This directly connects to Unit 3’s exploration of urbanization and the historical relationship between cities and green space. In Steinberg’s account of the 19th-century “organic city,” urban dwellers were intimately connected to nature through animals, gardens, and waste recycling—connections that…
Exercise #3: Connecting Past and Present
July 25, 2026 By: Matthew Coxon
Article 1: Daily Hive – “B.C. government signs major land use plan with First Nation on Vancouver Island” Link: https://dailyhive.com/vancouver/vancouver-island-namgis-first-nation-gwani-land-use-planning-project#google_vignette The Daily Hive article “B.C. government signs major land use plan with First Nation on Vancouver Island” provides a real-world example of how conservation in the present day continues to involve debates over how natural landscapes should be managed. The disagreement surrounding the land-use plan feels reminiscent of the Unit 3 discussions about the difference between Gifford Pinchot’s conservation philosophy, which emphasized scientific management of resources and John Muir’s preservation ethic, which viewed nature as valuable beyond economic interests. The…
Connecting Past and Present
July 18, 2026 By: Julia Morgan
Salt Spring Island BC Article: “Waterfront Property Donated” https://gulfislandsdriftwood.com/waterfront-property-donated-for-park/ A recent Gulf Islands Driftwood article notes that Ruth Baldwin’s family donated approximately 1.5 acres of oceanfront land at 215 Morningside Road to establish a community park on Salt Spring Island. The Salt Spring Island Archives indicate that the property was formerly home to David and Clara Maxwell, whose family had both Cowichan Indigenous and European ancestry, and that the land was used as a residence, a small farm, a gathering place, and an access point to the ocean. This history connects to Binnema and Niemi’s discussion of the parks movement because…
Exercise 3: Connecting Past and Present
July 6, 2026 By: David Kim
The first article chosen is about the recent 25% discount offered by Parks Canada for all parks under the jurisdiction of Parks Canada, while also simultaneously offering free admission for all travellers. Parks Canada states various benefits of Parks Canada, citing increased physical and mental health associated with visiting nature, which also helps lower health care costs across Canada. Parks Canada also views national parks as an excellent source of revenue both locally and nationally, as tourists actively contribute to the rising GDP. While Canada also highlights national parks, helping curb carbon footprints, I am reminded of the course readings…